Instance generator: geninst.pl Instance parameters: 10 50 200 25 0 20 10 40 20 75 1 1 Objective: makespan Technique: MIP (CPLEX 12.1.0) Time limit: 2h Id RLB BLB BUB GAP(%) Nodes Time 1 185.000 185.000 185.000 0.00 0 0.83 2 184.000 184.000 184.000 0.00 90 1.84 3* 178.000 183.000 183.000 0.00 42001 1908.88 4 179.000 179.000 179.000 0.00 84551 265.03 5 173.000 173.000 173.000 0.00 142 0.83 6 185.000 185.000 185.000 0.00 502 2.45 7 188.000 188.000 188.000 0.00 255 3.70 8# 171.000 171.000 ? inf 188100 7200.00 9 181.000 181.000 181.000 0.00 146 1.36 10 170.000 170.000 170.000 0.00 36959 105.67 inf = infinity RLB = lower bound at root node BLB = best known lower bound BUB = best known upper bound; equal to "?" if no feasible solution found GAP(%) = (BUB-BLB)/BUB; equal to "-" when infeasible Time given in seconds on a Pentium 4, 3.8Ghz, 4GB RAM, under GNU/Linux * NOTE: Instance 3 had to have its machine capacity raised to 29 to become feasible. # NOTE: If we let instance 8 run for 55 hours with the default MIP emphasis (balance optimality and feasibility), we get BLB=172 and BUB=175 after 1,404,279 nodes. The first feasible solution of value 186 is found after 2.7 hours and 282,285 nodes. The best feasible solution (175) is found after 3.8 hours and 442,952 nodes. If we run instance 8 for 55 hours with the MIP emphasis setting that looks for hidden feasible solutions, we get BLB=172 and BUB=173 after 1,074,000 nodes. The first feasible solution of value 186 is found after 2.5 hours and 282,285 nodes. The best feasible solution (173) is found after 47 hours and 1,043,242 nodes.